Missed part one? Find it
here!
When we left off, we had taken a look at the book and the market to come up with cool cover ideas. Not all of them are great, but they don't have to be-- that's the wonderful thing about brainstorming! Now we're going to make thumbnails out of some of those ideas and start drafting a cover or two.
Creating Thumbnails
The easiest way to make thumbnails might be grabbing a pencil and sketching it out on a piece of paper, which has the advantage of being infinitely flexible. I've found this method is too specific, though, since I won't be creating the source material for my cover and I need to keep an open mind. If you're lucky enough to be an artist, this is probably your best starting point.
Instead of drawing my thumbnails, I prefer to create them in a simple image editing program. I begin by collecting stock photos of my concept, making careful note of each picture's origin so I can contact the creator if I use it, and then layer them together.
Some great resources for stock photography include
stock.XCHNG,
Deviant Art, and
iStockPhoto. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages. stock.XCHNG is wonderful and free, but their catalog is limited, so the pictures tend to get around. I've seen a few indie covers with unmanipulated stock.XCHNG photos, and it's a little embarrassing. Deviant Art has varied photography with frequent updates from its userbase, but the quality isn't always great and you need to check with the artist to make sure you can use their stock for commercial purposes. iStockPhoto has images of fantastic quality and variety with an excellent searching mechanism, but they also get expensive.
You don't need a fancy editing program for thumbnails. Even MSPaint will do. I like to use
Pixlr, which is free and requires no download.
Here's a few thumbnails I cobbled together from the concepts I came up with in the last post.
 |
| 1.) A girl writing in her journal in front of the moon |
 |
| 2.) A journal in the forest with the moon overhead and a pool of blood beneath it |
 |
| 3.) Mountain with several phases of the moon passing overhead |
 |
| 4.) Wolf by the lake with multiple moon phases overhead |
Notice the iStockPhoto watermark on a couple of the thumbnails. I try to wait to buy my stock photos until I'm sure I'll use them, since the photos in that first cover alone cost $75. Yikes.
Any of this may change later. I don't want to get too specific here; I'm just trying to see if the execution of my ideas is as good as they sound in my head. These are deliberately sloppy and cheap-looking. We don't want to spend too much time making them look lovely, since we'll start over from scratch on the rough drafts anyway.
You'll note I don't have thumbnails for all the concepts, since I tried a couple of them and decided they were too dumb for even the minimal effort of thumbnails. #4 also came out of nowhere. Consistency isn't my bag, baby.
Analyze Your Covers
What are the positives and negatives of each cover concept? Be honest with yourself. I'm sure you like
all of them -- you made them, after all! -- but try to look at them from a practical standpoint.
1.)
A girl writing in her journal in front of the moon: I like that it features a girl who resembles the protagonist. You can probably guess it's YA at the very least. I'm not enthusiastic about this idea, though, and it's not just the $75 in photography I would need to buy. I don't want to develop this into a rough cover.
2.)
A journal in the forest with the moon overhead and a pool of blood beneath it: I was really enamored with this idea, but the execution isn't too hot. This looks more like horror than YA fantasy/romance. I will also not develop this one further.
3.)
Mountain with several phases of the moon passing overhead: I kind of like it. The idea is pretty and serene. I don't think you can guess what the book is about based on the cover, but I'm enamored with the moon phase idea. I'll make a draft of this one to see how I feel about it.
4.)
Wolf by the lake with multiple moon phases overhead: I like this one better. It uses the moon phase concept of which I'm growing fond, but the wolf makes the concept a little clearer. Most people connect the moon and wolves to werewolves. I don't like the wolf I used in the thumbnail, so I'll have to find a better one. I will also try a draft of this cover.
On the whole, I feel like I'm struggling to grasp the popular style of current covers. I admit I'm giving second thought to whether or not I
really need to have my wisdom teeth pulled, or if I could just go hire someone.
No! Impacted wisdom teeth hurt! Must design cover!
Phew. Moment of weakness. I'll take the designs I've liked so far and move on to...
Creating a Rough Draft
This is where the real work begins. You will want to use a better image editing program than MSPaint here. Pixlr has a lot of great features that might work if you're crafty.
The GIMP is kind of like a freeware version of Photoshop preferred by many poor people. I am blessed to possess a copy of Adobe Photoshop CS5 on my laptop and will use that.
I am not equipped to write Photoshop tutorials here. There's way too much to touch on. Take your time to read tutorials online with your friend The Google to learn techniques. I can't really recommend any tutorials in specific-- you'll have to look up what you need for your particular cover.
A few little tips:
- Leave ample space for your titles
- Consider "eye flow," which is where the viewer's gaze will be drawn by the layout of elements in your cover. Ideally, you want them to look over the cover and feel encouraged to open the book.
- Make the colors brighter than you think they need to be. They'll come out darker in print than on your screen.
- The file you work with must be VERY high resolution. My paperbacks will be 6" x 9". The file, therefore, is 6" x 9" at 300 dpi.
- Don't put anything critical against the edges of the cover. This is called the "bleed," I believe.
- Keep your elements large so it looks as good from a distance as it does up close. Imagine that your reader will see this on the shelf of a bookstore from at least a few feet away.
I began developing cover #3 up there by collecting stock images of the moon and doing a digital painting of a mountain and lake using another stock photo as reference. This was the result:
Okay, I already broke my tip about making a bright cover. I could modify this, but by the time I'm this far, I don't want to tweak it anymore. I think this image I created is lovely (although I might be biased) and I'm enamored with the multiple moon phases, but I don't want to spend any more time tweaking it.
First off, you can't really tell what the book is about. You also can't tell the genre. For all we know, it's literary fiction. And there's no real focus on the cover other than the moons. All in all, it's kind of pretty, but not a good cover.
By the way, I picked that font up off
DaFont. I thought it looked kind of like a sign at camp or something. Opinions have been mixed on this font, so I will probably experiment with other fonts later on different covers.
I moved onto designing cover #4 here. (For the record, I'm using stock art by DA users
ashensorrow and
moonsongstock right now.)
I like this a lot better. It still needs tweaking (too dark!) and I think I want to experiment with shades of brown on the cover since this cool blue doesn't really scream "summer."
But it's missing something. I'm not really sure what.
This is the part where we take our rough draft and move onto getting feedback so we can work on the final draft and getting ready for print. But we'll save that for
part three!
Are you working on your cover? I would love to see your work in progress in the comments!